CITY OF STIRLING
ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL
20 FEBRUARY 2001
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ITEM SUBJECT/LOCATION/NAME PAGE
1 PUBLIC QUESTION TIME 1
2 APOLOGIES AND LEAVE OF ABSENCE 2
3 CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES 2
3.1 ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL - 6 FEBRUARY 2001 2
4 BUSINESS ARISING FROM THE MINUTES AND NOT APPEARING SEPARATELY IN THE AGENDA 3
5 APPLICATION FOR LEAVE OF ABSENCE 3
6 MAYORAL BUSINESS 3
7 BUSINESS LEFT OVER FROM THE PREVIOUS MEETING 3
8 QUESTIONS WITH NOTICE WITHOUT DISCUSSION 3
9 PETITIONS 3
10 LATE & URGENT BUSINESS 4
10.1 DISTRICT PLANNING SCHEME NO. 2, AMENDMENT NO. 323/LOT 422,
HN 260 WOODSIDE STREET, DOUBLEVIEW/ESTATE REALITIES 4
10.2 LEGAL AGREEMENT (ROAD WIDENING) /LOT 1, HN 776 BEAUFORT
STREET, MT LAWLEY/STARVALLEY PTY LTD 5
10.3 EVERINGHAM STREET SAFETY ISSUES (ROAD REDIRECTION) /EVERINGHAM STREET, CARINE 6
11 REPORTS OF COMMITTEE 7
MEETING OF THE TOWN PLANNING AND STATUTORY SERVICES COMMITTEE OF
13 FEBRUARY 2001
11.1/A1 COMMITTEE ACTION LIST 7
11.1/A2 INGLEWOOD AQUATIC & FITNESS CENTRE - VARIOUS CAPITAL
COMMITMENTS 7
11.1/A3 GRAFFITI CAMPAIGN SEMINAR 8
11.1/A4 WAMA SPECIAL LGA ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING 8
11.1/A5 TEMPORARY ELECTORAL SIGNS/LOT 608P, HN 182, SCARBOROUGH
BEACH ROAD, DOUBLEVIEW/MR W McCURRY 9
ITEM SUBJECT/LOCATION/NAME PAGE
11.1/H1 VARIATION OF LIQUOR LICENCE - BALGA SOCCER & SOCIAL CLUB
(INC) /PRINCESS ROAD, BALGA/BALGA SOCCER & SOCIAL CLUB (INC) 9
11.1/H2 UNTIDY PREMISES/LOT PT 15, HN 420 KARRINYUP ROAD, GWELUP/
D.S. SILVESTRO & M. SILVESTRO 10
11.1/H3 ILLEGAL DISPOSAL OF ASBESTOS CEMENT MATERIAL/LOT 224 HN 6
EDGEHILL STREET, SCARBOROUGH/ZUPANOV BUILDING COMPANY 10
11.1/H4* RUBBISH ADVERSELY AFFECTING NEIGHBOURS/LOT 233 HN 14
DONGARA STREET, INNALOO/B.J. THOMPSON 11
11.1/CB1 PROPOSED BUILDING EXTENSIONS - INNALOO COMMUNITY CENTRE/
MORRIS PLACE, INNALOO/STIRLING PLAYERS THEATRE GROUP 11
11.1/CB2* OSBORNE PARK LIBRARY AND COMMUNITY CENTRE - REVIEW OF THE PROVISION OF HAIRDRESSING SERVICES/OSBORNE PARK LIBRARY
AND COMMUNITY CENTRE 12
11.1/B1*@ PRINCIPAL BUILDING SURVEYOR'S REPORT - JANUARY 2001 12
11.1/B2 PROPOSED SIGN STRATEGY - LOT 11/HN 227 MAIN STREET, OSBORNE PARK/CRYSTAL SHOPPING PLAZA 13
11.1/B3 PROPOSED WALL SIGNS - CLASSIC PRINTING AUSTRALIA/LOT 310 HN 20 SANGIORGIO COURT, OSBORNE PARK/CLASSIC PRINTING AUSTRALIA 13
11.1/B4 PROPOSED SIGN STRATEGY/LOT 10 HN 462 SCARBOROUGH BEACH
ROAD, OSBORNE PARK/RENAULT CAR DEALERSHIP 14
11.1/B5 PROPOSED SIGNS - WEST POINT STAR - MERCEDES BENZ/LOT 245
HN 472 AND LOT 246 HN 474 SCARBOROUGH BEACH ROAD, OSBORNE PARK/OLDFIELD KNOTT ARCHITECTS PTY LTD 14
11.1/B6 PROPOSED TWO STOREY DWELLING/LOT 65 HN 94 PARAMATTA ROAD, DOUBLEVIEW/B & G RUGGIERO 15
11.1/B7 SECONDARY STREET SETBACKS/LOT 12 HN 2 PEMBERTON CLOSE,
STIRLING/A & O DE PINHO 15
11.1/LA1*@ CLOSURE OF FOOTWAY RESERVE 26718 - NOLLAMARA/BETWEEN FLINDERS STREET AND KWEDA WAY, NOLLAMARA/OUR LADY OF
LOURDES PARISH 16
11.1/LA2 CLOSURE OF A CROWN PEDESTRIAN ACCESS WAY - STIRLING/
ABUTTING LOTS 75 & 76, HNS 8 & 10 JARDINE STREET AND LOTS 66
& 67, HNS 11 & 9 WHIMBREL STREET, STIRLING/MILEVSKI, WINDSOR,
BERTOLINI, GROW 16
11.1/LA3 CLOSURE OF A CROWN RIGHT OF WAY - STIRLING -/ABUTTING LOTS
136, 143 & 133 (HNS 690 - 694 KARRINYUP ROAD, STIRLING/WR
CARPENTER PROPERTIES - KOLTASZ SMITH & PARTNERS, NESA 17
11.1/LA4* WITHDRAWAL OF CAVEATS 17
11.1/LA5* RENEWAL OF LEASE/194 ROYAL STREET, YOKINE/TUART HILL
PRE-SCHOOL 18
ITEM SUBJECT/LOCATION/NAME PAGE
11.1/LA6 CLOSURE OF A CROWN FOOTWAY - DIANELLA/BETWEEN HANNABY
STREET AND MORLEY DRIVE, DIANELLA 18
11.1/LA7* PROPOSED ROAD CLOSURE CIVIC PRECINCT SITE/CNR HUGO STREET
AND CIVIC PLACE ABUTTING CITY OF STIRLING CIVIC CENTRE LANDHOLDINGS 19
11.1/LA8 SALE OF LAND - LOT 188 (HN 10) CORELLA STREET, STIRLING/
KRSTICEVIC 19
11.1/PL1* MANAGER'S REPORT - JANUARY 2001 20
11.1/PL2 PROPOSED POSTAL LOCALITY (SUBURB) BOUNDARY REALIGNMENT/NORTHWOOD ESTATE, MIRRABOOKA 20
11.1/PL3 THREE AGED PERSONS UNITS/LOT 826, HN 162 HANCOCK STREET, DOUBLEVIEW/HOMESWEST/ NOOR DI VIRGILIO & ASSOCIATES 20
11.1/PL4 METROPOLITAN NATIVE TITLE CLAIMS/RESERVED LAND IN THE CITY
OF STIRLING 21
11.1/PL5 FOUR AGED PERSONS DWELLINGS/LOT 575, HN 10 WALLER PLACE, INNALOO/HOMESWEST/NOOR DI VIRGILIO & ASSOCIATES PTY LTD 21
11.1/PL6 REQUEST TO DELETE CAVEAT AND LEGAL AGREEMENT/LOT 375, HN 21 PEARSON WAY, OSBORNE PARK/T A & G J MCALISTER 22
11.1/PL7* FRONT SCREEN WALLS AND CARPORTS/LOT 3, HN 28 DRAKE STREET, OSBORNE PARK/N & F DAMOPOULOS 22
11.1/PL8* MAIN STREET AND INGLEWOOD URBAN DESIGN PROJECTS - SIGNAGE
& DESIGN PROVISIONS 23
11.1/PL9 ONE ADDITIONAL GROUPED DWELLING/LOT 869, HN 15 BRAESIDE
ROAD, MT LAWLEY/KIM GRIFFITHS 23
11.1/PL10 AUTOMOTIVE SALES (MOTORCYCLES) /LOT 8, HN 106 FROBISHER
STREET, OSBORNE PARK/DONTICATION PTY LTD 24
11.1/PL11 TWELVE SINGLE BEDROOM UNITS/LOT 6798, HN 5 CARCOOLA STREET, NOLLAMARA/KENNETH YEWERS ARCHITECT/MINISTRY FOR HOUSING 24
11.1/PL12 COMMERCIAL VEHICLE IN A RESIDENTIAL AREA/LOT 51, HN 225B ODIN DRIVE, STIRLING/MR JOHN PATERSON 25
11.1/PL13 COMMERCIAL VEHICLES IN A RESIDENTIAL AREA (X2)/LOT 47, HN 9 VIEW STREET, DIANELLA/LOT 25, HN 3 WOODROW AVENUE, YOKINE/
MR ARTHUR OGNENIS 25
11.1/PL14* FRONT FENCING AND SECURITY GATES/LOTS 100 & 101, HNs.30 & 30A SCARBOROUGH BEACH ROAD, SCARBOROUGH/FRASER PROJECTS BY DESIGN 26
11.1/PL15@ RESIDENTIAL DESIGN CODES REVIEW - FINAL COMMENTS 26
11.1/PL16* MUNICIPAL INVENTORY REVIEW 27
11.1/PL17 REAR DWELLING WITH PARAPET WALL ON SIDE BOUNDARY/LOT 45,
HN 79 LONSDALE STREET, YOKINE/NICK NARDELLI 27
ITEM SUBJECT/LOCATION/NAME PAGE
11.1/PL18* DIANELLA PLAZA COMMERCIAL AND CIVIC PRECINCT 28
11.1/PL19 COMMERCIAL VEHICLE IN RESIDENTIAL AREA - LOT 623/HN 25 CUNNINGHAM LOOP, MIRRABOOKA/MR PETER SAVY 28
11.1/PL20*@ MIRRABOOKA ENQUIRY BY DESIGN WORKSHOP FINAL REPORT 29
11.1/PL21 ADDITIONAL STOREY & TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITY - INDIAN
OCEAN HOTEL/LOT 2, HN 23 HASTINGS STREET, SCARBOROUGH/
W GROVE 29
11.1/PL22 CONSULTING ROOMS (CHIROPRACTIC CLINIC) /LOT 163, HN 84
MORLEY DRIVE, TUART HILL/ROBERT LEE MATTIN 30
11.1/PL23 AUTOMOTIVE - MARINE SALES AND REPAIR/HN 430 (LOT 501)
WANNEROO ROAD,WESTMINSTER/GRAYIST PTY LTD 30
12 ADMINISTRATION REPORTS 31
13 MOTIONS, OF WHICH NOTICE WAS GIVEN BEFORE THE MEETING 33
14 MOTIONS, OF WHICH NOTICE WAS GIVEN DURING THE MEETING, TO BE
* - Indicates Separate Attachments submitted with Agenda.
@ - Indicates Councillor Interest.
MINUTES OF THE ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS, CIVIC PLACE, STIRLING ON TUESDAY 20 FEBRUARY 2001
Present: |
Mayor |
Councillor D C Vallelonga JP |
Deputy |
Councillor D Boothman | |
Councillors |
T W Clarey, J Copley JP, R J Daniel, B R Ham, G Italiano, E S Martin, P L Rose JP, A A Spagnolo JP, W M Stewart, T J Tyzack and R M Willox JP | |
Officers |
Chief Executive Officer - M J Wadsworth, Deputy Chief Executive Officer - R A Constantine, Executive Manager Works - R Moody, Executive Manager Development - S Johnson, Executive Manager Community Services - T Holland, Executive Manager Corporate & Customer Services - C Watts, Manager Administrative Services - F Bentley, Communications Co-ordinator - P Flynn, Administration Officer - S Billingham and Administration Officer - D Gardner | |
Public |
12 | |
Press |
2 |
DECLARATION OF OPENING OF MEETING
The Mayor declared the ordinary meeting of Council on 20 February 2001 open at 7.00pm.
APOLOGIES
Councillor J M Camilleri OAM JP
1.1 K Lenke, 29b Newborough Street, Scarborough
Q1 Yes the Mayor did offer an amount of $2500 to settle a claim of compensation for the loss of our pool. I ask the Council who of you would accept this offer when the quotes to restore the pool would exceed $8000, and the quotes to fill in the now dangerous concrete hole were at least $4000 with the very real potential to rise above this figure when including the possible damage to septics, fencing paving, reticulation etc. in the process? Not of course counting the many thousands of dollars and 10 years it has taken to bring this issue to this point and not taking into account of course all the trumped up legal costs and penalty interest charges the Council has imposed in the meantime to intimidate us into backing off in our pursuit for justice. Nor taking into account the fact this needless heavy-handed approach by Council resulted in our property being devalued by as much as $30,000. Leave it to a pensioner to pay for your cockups - is that what this Council considers acceptable? And how many of you, sitting here tonight, would be prepared to accept this offer, which by the way came with other "riders" attached, and believe it be a sincere attempt to resolve, rather than the way it was intended. That is - as an insult?
A1 No response was provided.
1.2 E McNeil, 72 Eldorado Street, Tuart Hill
Q1 Why were the minutes of the Special Electors Meeting held January 31 amended? These minutes are not a true and accurate report.
A1 The Chief Executive Officer responded:
I don't believe they were amended, but if the questioner would provide me with the details, I will investigate the matter. I don't believe the issue has been raised prior to tonight's meeting. It is no problem to have the matter investigated as the meeting was taped and we can act accordingly.
1.3 T Parker, 1 Chellaston Crescent, Carine
Q1 Could Council consider the installation of a roundabout at the intersection of Edlaston and Osmaston Roads, Carine?
A1 The Mayor responded:
The City would further investigate the matter and respond accordingly.
1.4 L Scott, 18 Cedric Street, Stirling
Q1 Is it not part of the Local Government Act that Councillors show courtesy and understanding towards ratepayers?
A1 No response provided.
1.5 R Mitchell, 9 Clark Place, Karrinyup
Q1 When is this Council going to stop the illegal use of crown land for market gardening at Lake Gwelup on the Segrave Street alignment and boundary?
A1 The Mayor responded
That a public meeting had been held with the property owners and the matter of the proposed alignment of Segrave Street had not been resolved.
The Executive Manager Development responded
That if the market gardening is on crown land and this has been going on for some years they may enjoy a non-conforming use right. The Executive Manager Development undertook to investigate the matter.
Councillor J M Camilleri OAM JP
Moved Councillor Rose, seconded Councillor Willox
That the apology be noted.
The motion was put and declared CARRIED.
Moved Councillor Spagnolo, seconded Councillor Rose
That the Minutes of the Council meeting of 6 February 2001 be confirmed, and signed by the Mayor as a true and correct record of proceedings subject to the correction of;
Item 11.1/EO1 point 3 - the word `ADVISED' be replaced with `CONSULTED'
Item 14.2 to be deleted and replaced with
Councillor Ham gave notice at the meeting of 6 February 2001 that he intends to move the following motion at the next ordinary meeting of Council:-
"That all reports presented to Council be signed by the Originating Officer, Manager and Executive Manager."
The motion was put and declared CARRIED.
Councillor Stewart advised the meeting that he intended to move the revocation of Item 11.1/RR2 from Council 6 February 2001 through official processes.
NIL.
Moved Councillor Martin, seconded Councillor Copley
That Councillor Boothman be GRANTED Leave of Absence from 26 February 2001 to 12 March 2001.
That Councillor Clarey be GRANTED Leave of Absence 27 February 2001 and 6 March 2001.
The motion was put and declared CARRIED.
NIL.
NIL.
NIL.